Lo3
Hypodermic Needle
Theory and The Uses and Gratifications Theory are two theories used for
audience profiling. They are used to understand your audience and therefore
allow companies to be able to predict and utilise the best ways to market a
product to their audience.
Hypodermic Needle
Theory
“The "Magic
Bullet" or "Hypodermic Needle Theory" of direct influence
effects was not as widely accepted by scholars as many books on mass
communication indicate. The magic bullet theory was not based on empirical findings
from research but rather on assumptions of the time about human nature. People
were assumed to be "uniformly controlled by their biologically based
'instincts' and that they react more or less uniformly to whatever 'stimuli'
came along" (Lowery & De Fleur, 1995, p. 400). The "Magic
Bullet" theory graphically assumes that the media's message is a bullet
fired from the "media gun" into the viewer's "head" (Berger
1995). Similarly, the "Hypodermic Needle Model" uses the same idea of
the "shooting" paradigm. It suggests that the media injects its
messages straight into the passive audience (Croteau, Hoynes 1997). This
passive audience is immediately affected by these messages. The public
essentially cannot escape from the media's influence, and is therefore
considered a "sitting duck" (Croteau, Hoynes 1997). Both models
suggest that the public is vulnerable to the messages shot at them because of
the limited communication tools and the studies of the media's effects on the
masses at the time (Davis, Baron 1981).”
•
Source
Wikipedia
Contributing factors
•
Increase of
popularised media (television and radio)
Passive audiences
that consume mass media produced content all tend to enjoy and consume the same
things, talk to each other about it and spread the idea making it more and more
popular.
•
Industries
persuasion by advertising and manipulation of public opinion
Mass medias
advertising can convince a passive audience that their new media content is
“the hottest most important” content manipulating them into thinking they
should watch it to keep up with the latest trends.
•
Impact of
motion pictures on children (Payne Fund studies in the 1930’s)
Disney is a prime
example of how motion pictures can indoctrinate children to have certain
ideologies and values, young girls watch motion pictures like Cinderella and
Snow White and therefore want to be princesses when they grow up, live in a
castle and marry prince charming whereas boys take away the ideas that they
need to be strong masculine figures to win a woman’s affection. All of these
are very traditional values that are put into children’s minds from a very
young age and are argued to be a form of brainwashing.
•
Hitler’s
Nazi Party (Monopolising the mass media during World War Two)
Many dictators
control their countries media to brainwash their countries citizens into
thinking a certain way, Hitler did things like ban any non-Nazi media and pump
the German citizens full of anti-sematic, anti-homosexual and other racist
messages to make them ask less questions and make them easier to control. The
exact same thing is happening in North Korea at present date, media control for
brainwashing of the nation which seems to be an effective tool in control.
Hypodermic needle
theory is a theory which states that the media affectively controls the mind of
the consumer by showing them what they think they should be interested in thus
having the effect of making the consumer value what the media is showing them
just because it’s in the media. For example a hit TV series such as “The Only Way
Is Essex” that is watched by millions may only be popular because there is so
much media coverage and the viewer’s become interested in the show because so
much of it is thrust upon them subconsciously that they almost get brainwashed
into enjoying the show, The same can be said for other hit TV shows such as the
X Factor and Britain’s Got Talent. This is because the mass media conveys its
ideologies onto the opinion leader (someone who other follow, style icons EG
Justin Bieber) and then individuals who idolise the opinion leader will follow
that person thus indoctrinating the audience into liking what the mass media
produces.
Uses and
Gratifications Theory
Uses and
gratifications theory hold the idea that “audience members are not passive consumers of media. Rather, the
audience has power over their media consumption and assumes an active role in
interpreting and integrating media into their own lives. Unlike other
theoretical perspectives, UGT holds that audiences are responsible for choosing
media to meet their desires and needs to achieve gratification. This theory
would then imply that the media compete against other information sources for
viewers' gratification.”
• Source Wikipedia
This theory
believes that the consumers of media chose their own forms of entertainment and
therefore are responsible to the mainstream media that they consume as the
media companies interpret what the public enjoys and so creates it for them.
This is the exact opposite of the Hypodermic need (or Magic Bullet) theory and
the two cannot be mixed as they are direct contradictions of each other. An
example of this would be that large TV shows such as The X factor and others
are so popular because the masses genuinely enjoy their content, and so they
keep coming back season after season because it’s what the audience wants to
see and enjoys. In short the general public uses the media to meet their own
satisfaction.
Sociologists
Blumler and Katz first began studying this theory in the 1930's however they
recieved a lot of critisim as it is almost impossible to determine someones
gratification of needs (what makes someone happy) as it is too ambigous and the
information was based upon surveys alone so is not a solid way of measuring how
people consume media.
Effects Debates
Explicit content -
The reason legally the public must know about explicit content in any form of
media is the effect it can have on young children, this is why we see
disclaimers on things like CD cases, Television shows and why there are age
ratings on films and games. It is argued that these things can cause younger
more impressionable people to do the things that they see as they think its
acceptable. A prime example of this would be Manhunt, a video game that came
out in 2003 that was very violent. In Feburary 2004 two friends decided to
recreate the game and one was stabbed to death as a result. Because of this
stores starting taking the game off of the shelves and the game was banned.
(story below)
Advertising a
better life - This form of advertising is most common as its philosophy is
simple and understandable, if a company shows someone using their product to
enrich their own lives others will buy this product to do the same. The most
obvious example of this kind of advertising is adverts for holidays or cruises,
they depict people, ususally idyllic family smiling and having fun doing all
sorts of activities (leading a better life). The idea is that the consumer
see's this and so buys the product to try and reach the level of content shared
by those in the advert.
Celebrity
endorsement - This is also a very common form of advertisement, celebrities are
style icons, the public want to be famous and live celebrity life styles.
Because of this if a very famous person is saying "Buy this product, I use
it" those who idolise that celebrity are likely to buy. A good example of
this is David and Victoria Beckhams fragence collection which generates a lot
of income each year because those who idolise them want to smell like they do,
they associate the celebrity couple with class and money and they want to be
the same.
No comments:
Post a Comment